Amazon Echo vs Google Home: Which Should I Choose?

Amazon Echo vs Google Home

What would an Amazon Echo vs Google Home duel look like? “Hey…” is something that you’ll hear often in most houses everywhere. But nobody is trying to catch the eye of others, or even misbehaving kids, or drifting pets. We’re tripping our voice assistants.

Google and Amazon have worked hard to create ecosystems that have us barking orders to applications, turning lights off, putting reminders, playing with music and more.

But which is better?

Google Home 

One of Google Home benefits is using Google Assistant. Its predictive intelligence keeps the show running. You receive an answer that will most likely be exactly what you’re looking for and can ask Google just about anything. The Google home shows full-text responses including incremental recipes and directions. Google Home also helps you stay alert when you have to leave for your next appointment based on schedule and finally, offers calendar reminders: well that’s if you are using Google’s productivity package and organizational tools.

When you’ve bought into Google smart home systems, then you are able to do even more, like controlling your Nest services and products such as your toaster or any other smart product that works with Google Home. There are other abilities as well beyond Google, such as interacting with the internet and making online purchases with Walmart and Amazon. 

All You Need to Know About Google Home 

You’ve already made your decision and bought among Google’s smart speakers or even smart displays and you would like to know what you should do with it.

I can provide help. Below, I will familiarize you with everything you’re able to do when you are working and also with the fundamentals of the Google Home app. I’ll also examine the flaws of this device and what’s next for Google’s smart dwelling.

If you are not sure whether you want a Google Home, an Amazon Echo or perhaps an Apple HomePod, we will assist with that, too. We have a comprehensive guide that can assist you in your bid to buy a smart speaker. We also have a breakdown of the three main digital assistants developed into smart speakers — Google Assistant, Amazon’s Alexa and Apple’s Siri all included.

What is Google Home?

This smart speaker by the search giant was made to contend with the favorites Amazon Echo. The Google Home can play music, but it’s primarily designed as a carrier for Google Assistant. Even the Google Assistant you get is just like the one available on recent Android mobiles such as the Google Pixel 3A.

The Google Home is always listening to its own environment, but it won’t record what you are saying or respond to your orders until you say one with its pre-programmed wake words –which could be either”OK, Google” or even “Hey, Google”. 

Google has three smart speakers. Google Assistant surfaced in the initial $100 Google Home. The $50 Google Home Mini squeezes all the smarts of the initiative into a smaller, more affordable package. The $300 Google Home Max puts Google’s smarts to a speaker designed to deliver superior sound.

All three speakers grant you access to the Google Assistant service. They differ in size, sound price, and quality. You use the exact same Google Home app to set up all three, and all of them answer the same wake words and commands.

You can also use Google Assistant by way of a variety of third-party smart speakers such as the mobile TicHome Mini and the JBL Hyperlink series. Even the Sonos One will probably work with Google Assistant as well, though Sonos has been assuring clients of an upgrade for a while. Unless it’s expressly stated differently, all the Google Home features I discuss below function with almost any Google Assistant-enabled smart speaker.

Amazon Echo 

The Amazon Echo is more of an extension of the Amazon experience. It could do a lot of things, but it is better at helping you find services and products to buy on Amazon and enjoy the music and videos that come with your Prime membership. With Amazon’s Alexa, anything important can be purchased with a phrase and you can be sure it will be added into your cart. (Unfortunately, the days of instantly buying something with just your voice came to an end after a few highly publicized incidents in which toddlers went on Alexa-assisted toy shopping sprees).

Frankly, if you have Amazon Prime, you almost definitely need to have an Alexa device to finish your membership. The music and video library you can obtain through an apparatus is prodigious. Alexa can tell you when it believes you’re getting low on frequently purchased items, whenever your orders will be arriving (sometimes), and just generally is an invaluable assistant. This smart home assistant does things like putting timers and alerts, changing dimensions and creating reminders.

There is also an ecosystem of Amazon-branded IoT devices and smart programs that use Alexa as their smart home interface than there is for Google Home. As regarding giving guidelines — or whatever involves the real world or managing my program I actually don’t turn to Alexa. While Amazon has plenty of skills to make it smarter, it still falls short as soon as the questions get complex.

All You Need to Know Concerning Amazon Echo Dot

The Amazon Echo Dot is a hockey puck-shaped smart speaker and a compact form of the initial Amazon Echo.

You can use voice commands in an Amazon Echo Dot through an Alexa personal assistant to answer questions, play the news headlines, play music, along also with other countless tasks. 

The Amazon Echo Dot is a smaller variant of their first Amazon Echo smart speaker. Appearing much like a hockey puck than the Echo’s initial cylindrical contour, the Dot measures only just a little more than 3 inches in diameter and is nearly 1.5 inches high.

There are a couple of buttons at the top that control volume, mute the speaker and wake the device to listen to a question or control (though you never need to touch the Dot to use it; it is designed to primarily answer voice commands).

The Amazon Echo Dot can be really just a streamlined smart speaker system that responds to voice commands. 

Like the original Amazon Echo, the Echo Dot is a voice-controlled smart speaker that uses an artificially intelligent assistant named Alexa to perform a broad range of tasks. Alexa can play music, set alerts, control other smart devices in the home, play games, and also answer questions by searching for information online, just to mention some of its various skills.

How The Amazon Echo Dot Differs From Other Echo Devices (Similarities Included)

The Echo Dot is primarily different from other Echo devices in that it is missing the large speaker which occupies most of the original Echo’s cylinder. It’s a far smaller, somewhat lesser speaker. However, it can be linked using either a normal cable or Bluetooth. The previous Echo could not be connected to an outside speaker.

The Amazon Echo Dot can play through a nearby speaker using a normal audio jack or Bluetooth. 

Otherwise, the Dot is indistinguishable to the Echo — it is capable of doing all the functions of almost any other model in the Amazon Echo family. Even the Alexa assistant works exactly the same and may draw from exactly the same library of activities and skills.

In the event that you currently possess one type of Echo product and want speakers to get different rooms at home, it is possible to mix and match. An Amazon Echo Dot can work in a home along with other Amazon Echo and Echo Dot speakers.

 Amazon Echo services and products cannot transfer information from one device to another and are also not aware of each other in the same residence.  They balance this lapse with a mic technology that they possess. This mic technology ensures the Echo that’s nearest will receive and act on voice commands — convenient if you’ve got multiple Amazon Echo services and products at a small house or apartment.

Other Speakers in the Amazon Echo Family 

Amazon has continued the expansion of the range of its Amazon Echo product family within the past few years. Besides Amazon Echo, Amazon additionally also offers the Echo Plus to smart homes. The Echo plus is shaped just like a cylinder but has an integrated Zigbee hub to get a handle on Zigbee-compatible smart home devices.

The Echo Spot is what you would get if you inserted a display to an Echo Dot. Amazon intends the Spot to be used on a nightstand as an alarm clock that can respond to voice commands and display information on the small screen.

The Echo Spot is just another streamlined variant of the Amazon Echo, this one having a display and intended to function as an assistant. 

Finally, the Echo show can be an Echo packed into a tablet condition, built to lay on a desk or table having a 7-inch screen. Amazon has made this Echo ideal for watching videos and making calls.

Amazon Echo vs Google Home: Sound Features 

As you’d expect from such a range of shapes and sizes, you get quite a good sound performance across both ecosystems when comparing Amazon Echo to Google Home generally. Following is a wide breakdown of how they sound to each other.

The latest Google Nest Mini is a product that sounds better also, with the inclusion of an extra speaker.

If you’re searching for an Echo speaker, your best bet then is the Echo Spot, which despite its size, offers a richer sound. If you don’t need a screen, the Echo Dot with Clock is an attractive choice.

The Google Home is too bass-heavy to be enjoyable, as you move up the size scale. It has better clarity than the latest generation of the Amazon Echo speaker including the Echo Plus. However, if you are confined to about $100, the new Amazon Echo (2019) could be the best choice from a sound perspective.

Having a small premium in price and the inclusion of Dolby processing, the Echo Plus audio is livelier than the standard Echo, as you would expect — that the Echo Studio should improve on this further, and we’ll be sure to update this article after we’ve analyzed it thoroughly.

And, despite its looks, the Echo Show seems better than the Echo Plus and Echo, although not so as to forgive it a number of its other failings.

If you’re going for pure superiority involving the Echo and Google Home ranges, however, go for the Google Home Max. Its bass is well-tuned, its highs and mid are well-defined, and its volume is loud without crossing into an outrageously loud zone.

Verdict

Each voice assistant has its area of specialty. Try to buy something on Google Home and you will get an experience that is fairly unsatisfying.  Attempt to manage your calendar or access complex knowledge with Amazon Alexa and you are going to end up triggering one of its curt responses to cursing.

In the case where you have Amazon Prime, you need an Alexa device of some type. Without one, you are leaving a good part of your membership to the table’s worth. And if you’re a frequent Amazon shopper, then it is the only way to access the website without the internet or the app. Additionally, it is a smart tool hub.

Google Home, in contrast, is for those who live and die by Google. If you rely on to keep a calendar, give you traffic upgrades, search for recipes and assist you to themes, Home is going to be quite a welcome extension to your smart property toolkit. Of course, in case you have a broad Play library or manage your photos on Google, a Home Hub can be a satisfying device.

So which one do you get? For smart home control, Alexa has significantly more partners. For intelligence, Google has got the edge. If you only want to look and listen to music on your countertop, The Echo could be your thing. However, in case you’d love to see what else an AI assistant can do, then check out Google Home.

The smartest thing to do is to try both and see what one fits better with the way you live.

Amazon Echo vs Google Home FAQs: Quick Questions Answered 

  • Is Alexa better than Google? That’s a tough question because they’re both similar and we find it difficult to pick between the two. Which one you decide to go with may well depend on which you personally prefer and what kind of products you’re using than which is technically ‘better’.  Having said that, Alexa tends to be better when it comes to supporting a wider range of devices, as well as better smart home integration. So if you have a lot of smart home devices already, Alexa might be your best bet.  However, lots of users who have put the two devices head-to-head believe Google Assistant could be the smarter of the two. And, with Google’s A.I. learning experience, it has the biggest potential for the future. 
  • Is there a monthly fee for the Echo? No. You don’t have to pay anything extra after you’ve purchased an Echo product. Although you do get some perks if you’re an Amazon Prime member, like access to Amazon Music.
  • Can Alexa drop in on Google Home? No. Alexa’s Drop-In feature only works with other Alexa-enabled devices. 
  • What’s the difference between Echo and Google Home? As we’ve said above – very little right now. They’re both very capable smart assistants that respond to voice commands and work well with many smart home devices. Read our full head-to-head below to get a better idea of the specifics. 
  • Which is the best Alexa speaker to buy? It really depends on what your needs are; if you want something with a screen try the Amazon Echo Show. Looking to save money? Try the budget-friendly Echo Dot. While this guide will focus on Echo speakers, Alexa is built-in to a number of third party speakers these days, including the Sonos One. 
  • What works with Google Home? With Google Assistant, your Google Home can control your Philips Hue lightbulbs, Honeywell thermostat, Nest security camera, and smart TV (as long as it’s compatible). Check out our roundup of things Google Assistant can do for more info, or head to the Google Assistant partners page for all the brands Google Home can work with.
  • Is Google home compatible with Alexa? Like Amazon’s Alexa devices — and recently, the Echo, Echo Dot, Tap and the new Echo Look camera — the Google Home supports plenty of third-party streaming services, like Pandora, Spotify, and TuneIn. However, with a Google Home, you can also stream from YouTube Music, so long as you’re a YouTube Red subscriber
  • Can Google Assistant and Alexa work together? The answer is both. Both the Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa offer plenty of connected home prowess. They’re both capable of answering the same questions, executing the same smart home commands, and performing the same tricks. You shouldn’t have any trouble using a Google Home right next to an Amazon Echo device
  • Is there a monthly fee for Alexa? Is there a monthly fee associated with Alexa? There is no monthly fee to use the tap. You have access to free services such as iheart radio, TuneIn and Pandora. There are services the tap offers that does require a monthly fee such as Spotify but it is your choice to use that service or not.
  • Does Google home have a monthly fee?  There is no monthly fee. You can use the free version of Spotify, Tunein, etc for music. All you really need is a google account, which is also free. You use the Google Home app on your smartphone to set up your Google Home.

Profzubby

I am a tech enthusiast. Since the Smart Home tech came out I fell in love with it and have been following it ever since. I decided to use this platform to pour out my knowledge and experience I've had overtime to guide your decisions. Hope the experience is worth your while.

Recent Posts